Jawbone vs Fitbit: Pros and Cons

In

Buying an activity tracker can be a tough choice, especially when you're debating the merits of Jawbone vs Fitbit, the two most popular brands of activity trackers. There is no doubt about the fact that activity tracking is important if you want to stay healthy and fit. In a world where everyone is all too often lost in the craze of earning a living, most of us might well end up forgetting to check ourselves for fitness.

Thanks to the technology of activity trackers, we can now check ourselves for most of the activities that contribute to our bodies’ well-being. Technologically advanced fitness activity trackers, which are what we have in the market today, can track a range of activities, depending on the brand and purpose. These activities include:

  • heartbeat
  • steps
  • sleep
  • runs
  • bike rides
  • swims
  • mountain climbs

Fitness trackers have taken the wristband fashion, and that fashion is here to stay. Most of what you will be looking for when shopping for a fitness activity tracker will be what it can do for you and its fashion. These brands have been the rival trackers and the battle of Jawbone vs Fitbit continues. You'll need to check out each one of them very closely to decide which one you will buy.

What are the Merits of Each Fitness Tracker?

Splurge

FitBit

Charge HR 2

Let's dig in to the most popular band offered by each competitor. We'll start with the Fitbit Charge HR 2.

Fitbit

This year, the Fitbit Charge HR 2 is the one that seems to come out on top with its competitor, Jawbone UP3. Its looks and wearability are as follows:

  • Flexible and durable elastomer
  • surgical-grade stainless steel buckle – may cause skin irritation in some people
  • 3 sizes available, catering for wrist sizes 5.5-9.1 inches
  • 34mm thick
  • 4 color choices- black, blue, plum and tangerine
  • OLED display
  • splashproof

This is how it works:

  • 24/7 heart-rate monitor that uses PurePulse technology
  • Heart-rate monitor is 100% accurate when in rather calm activity, during vigorous activity, the accuracy is a little deterred
  • Heart-rate monitoring when resting is rather inaccurate
  • Tracks steps taken, floors climbed, distance traveled and overall active minutes
  • Tracks calories burnt
  • Displays real-time recordings on the LED display when on exercise mode
  • Simply tracks how many hours of sleep you get
  • Sleep monitor is automatic with a silent alarm (vibration-mode)
  • Five days battery life
  • Costs about $125, depending on the merchant

It also has a Fitbit app which allows you to do the following:

  • See progress
  • Record workouts
  • Log your food intake
  • Compete amongst each other
  • Earn badges according to the record of your activity

Save
jawbone up3

Jawbone

UP3

Jawbone

The Jawbone UP3 is currently much cheaper than the Fitbit Charge HR2, but it is also an older model. The UP4 has been announced, although it has yet to be released. If you're looking to save on your activity tracker, taking advantage of the current deal on UP3 may be a good move. However, many users complain about having to manually switch between sleep and waking mode and the band's propensity to loosen or fall off by itself.

  • 12.2mm thick
  • One size available with an adjustable clasp said to fit on any wrist (not known to cause irritation)
  • Several color choices available, including silver cross, black diamond, red, teal, sand and indigo
  • Thinnest and lightest fitness activity tracker on the market
  • splashproof
  • Different lights indicating certain activities and notifications

About how it works:

  • 24/7 heart-rate monitor
  • Heart-rate monitor works on a multi-sensor technology, which gives a better resting heart-rate
  • Tri-axis accelerometer
  • bioimpedance sensors
  • Skin and ambient temperature sensors
  • Tracks steps taken, floors climbed, distance traveled and overall active minutes
  • Tracks calories burnt
  • If you are inactive for too long, it nudges you
  • Automatic Sport detection skills
  • Great sleep accuracy with an automatic sleep detector which differentiates between REM (Rapid Eye Movement), light and deep sleep
  • Seven days battery life
  • Costs about $100, depending on the merchant.

How the Jawbone UP3 works:

  • 24/7 heart-rate monitor
  • Heart-rate monitor works on a multi-sensor technology, which gives a better resting heart-rate
  • Tri-axis accelerometer
  • bioimpedance sensors

Our Choice

Choosing a fitness tracker obviously is a personal decision -- some value knowing their heart rates, others the number of flights climbed, others just want the number of steps they're taking. But overall, we recommend the Fitbit Charge HR 2 over the Jawbone UP3. It's got more features, is more comfortable to wear, and lasts longer.